The article highlights the pressing challenges in managing mackerel and Atlanto-Scandian herring stocks in the North-East Atlantic, exacerbated by climate change and overfishing. Despite scientific advice, countries like Norway, Iceland, and the EU have set quotas beyond recommended limits, threatening long-term sustainability. Climate change is causing fish to migrate, complicating management across political boundaries. The Marine Stewardship Council calls for adherence to scientific advice and climate-ready strategies to prevent stock collapse. The article underscores the need for adaptive management systems and international cooperation to ensure sustainable fisheries amid changing ocean conditions and rising seafood demand, emphasizing the low environmental impact of sustainably caught wild fish.